A United Methodist Pastor's Theological Reflections

"But thanks be to God, who gives us the victory (nikos) through our Lord Jesus Christ." - I Corinthians 15:57


Friday, October 9, 2015

If Only Job Had a Stephen Minister!


This Sunday, our church will begin a three-part sermon series on the Book of Job. As I've been preparing for this sermon series, I was reminded of what a difficult read this book is!

Your heart just goes out to this poor guy. Yes, he was wealthy and had the good life, but it all vanished in a moment when one terrible thing happened after another. Very early into the story of Job, we find him lonely, depressed, and ill.

If that wasn't bad enough, check out Job's so-called friends! They are quick to point out to him that his sufferings are most likely the result of some unconfessed sin or sins that he has committed. Their theology is very simple. If bad things happen to you, you must have done something wrong. Job's friends represent the prevailing theology of the time period when the Book of Job was written. 

Disobey God and Sin = Bad Things Will Happen to You
Obey God and Don't Sin = Good Things Will Happen to You

Before we try to dismiss this thinking as too simplistic, we find this theology in scripture! The Book of Deuteronomy uses this theology a lot because it was emphasizing the importance of being holy and upright. Think of what we share with our children when we want them to study in school. "Do your homework and you'll do well on your test!"

The problem is that this doesn't always hold true! Sometimes bad things happen to good people even when they did everything they were supposed to do! This is the case with Job and it's why this book of the Bible was written. It was written to remind the people of Israel that sometimes life stinks and it has nothing to do with anything bad you may have done. The Book of Job is the other side of the theological coin regarding why do bad things happen to people. Sometimes it's because of something we have done, but sometimes it's just because that's the way life can be.



Job's friends have no clue that there is another side of this theological coin, so they stick with what they know by blaming Job for his sins which we as the readers of the story know that he hasn't committed. If only Job had a good friend from whom he could have received some support!



This is why I wish Job had a Stephen Minister. A Stephen minister is someone who has received extensive training in the art of listening and offering peer support for someone who is going through a difficult time in their life. Our church is blessed to have several Stephen Ministers. 

As we begin this series on Job, we are invited to enter into the theological struggle with him as to why bad things happen to people from time to time. It's not an easy question that has simple answers. 

Poor Job! Here, he had lost everything and he also had to put up with these unsympathetic friends.

If only Job had a Stephen Minister! 

Wednesday, October 7, 2015

The Miracle of the Magic Wand - Summary of Get Acquainted Gatherings (Athens First UMC)


[The famous magic wand used at each of the five Get Acquainted sessions in answering the question, "What miracle does God want to do through our church?]

A big thank you to the people who hosted the five Get-Acquainted gatherings these past few months. The purpose of these gatherings was to help me as the new pastor learn about what you like most about First UMC and where you believe God is leading us in the future.

These are the comments that I heard the most frequently.

What you like most about your church? (Most Heard Comments)
  • Service Opportunities
  • Prayer Ministry
  • History of reaching out to the university community
  • Music Ministry
  • Sunday School Program
  • Relationships
  • Willingness to try new things
What miracle do you want to see happen through our church? (Most Heard Comments)
  • A strong college student ministry
  • Continued emphasis on prayer
  • Building enhancements
  • Increase number of people using gifts in ministry through the church
  • More small groups
  • Stronger finances and build up staff team
  • Seeing our children's ministry grow
  • Support for widows and widowers/elderly members
  • Worship attendance growth
  • Mission work locally
  • Growth for Monday Lunch & Growing Tree Pre-School
  • Revitalization of previous ministries like the puppets
For the question regarding what miracle God wants to do through our church, I had everyone hold a magic wand when they answered the question. It was a fun way of allowing ourselves to use our imagination in thinking about what God wants to do through us. Some people liked the magic wand so much that they didn't want to give it to the next person!

Thank you for your responses and for thinking and praying with me about our future together here at First UMC. We are off to a great start!

Grace and Peace,

Pastor Robert

Disclaimer: That was not a "real" magic wand. It was purchased in the toy section at Walmart. 


[One of five Get Acquainted gatherings. I look really tall in this picture!]

Tuesday, October 6, 2015

Dave's Deep Thoughts - Walking in the Dark

Here's Pastor Dave McDowell's weekly devotional that he sends out to members of his church. Dave is my brother and serves as the Music Minister at Stewartstown UMC in PA.

I am old enough to know there are things that go bump in the night…..
but someone should have warned me about the water hazards.

Gone are the days when I was able to sleep straight through the night.
An aging bladder has seen to that.

Because of that, whenever I am away from home for the night,
I make sure I know the path to the bathroom before I retire for the evening.

God may have promised to be with us through the valley of the shadows of death,
but I would also find it comforting to have a nightlight to get me through to the facilities.

Last summer, I was out of town to perform a wedding,
I stayed with the groom’s family in a rustic cabin.
The floors were creaky.
The doors opened with groans.

The bathroom was located at the top of a staircase.
My bedroom was down a narrow hallway.

I have heard it said,
“It is always darkest before they turn the lights on.”  *
In the middle of the night, with no nightlight,
this place was pitch black.

Because the bedrooms were so close to each other,
I didn’t want to turn on the lights and risk waking everyone up.

Like a kicker on a football team who retraces his steps before the big kick,
I analyzed every move that I would need to make in the dark.
I memorized the layout of the bathroom and
numbered my steps down the hallway.
I was ready for my nocturnal pilgrimage.

Like a bugler playing revelry in the army.
my bladder faithfully awoke me.

I moved to the door.
The unending creak as I opened it was worthy of any haunted house.
The snorers on the other side of the thin walls seem unbothered,

Eight and one-half steps down the hallway to the holy grail.
That would be eight and one-half steps until I ran into a wall.

I am not quite sure who moved the bathroom door after midnight,
but all of a sudden, I was completely disoriented.
It is one thing to be disoriented.
It is quite another to be disoriented in the pitch black at the top of a staircase.

Let me say that I do not mind dying.
But I do mind dying stupidly.
When people read my obituary,
it is not my preference that they laugh out loud.
What a poor man. He died in a vain attempt to find the toilet.”

Using every Helen Keller technique that I could muster,
I crawled on all fours till I found a door.
What I didn’t know was if it was the door to the bathroom or the neighboring master bedroom.

There are times in life when one just has to breathe deeply and take a chance.
The door moaned as I opened it slowly.
I sighed a sigh of relief as I felt a linoleum rather than a wooden floor.

Once inside the holy grail, I regained my composure.
That was, until I went to wash my hands.
In my early evening water closet boot camp,
I forgot to note that the water faucets on the sink were reversed.
Not reversed hot and cold, but reversed on and off.

When I couldn’t turn the faucet on,
I pushed it in the opposite direction.
This is when the water blasted out onto the sink which was so angled 
as to re-direct the water onto the foolish human that dared to use it.

In my attempt to avoid an undesirable encounter with liquids during the night,
I ended up soaked.

Life can at times,  feel a lot like walking in the dark.
The Bible has words four different words for darkness…..

The darkness of sin (disobedience) 
“Men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil.” John 3:19

The darkness of ignorance 
God is light and in Him is no darkness at all.” I John 1:5

The darkness of demonic forces
“But this hour and the power of darkness are yours.”  Luke 22:53b

But the 4th type of darkness is different than those which describe people who don’t walk with God.
It is a darkness that comes upon those who do love and walk with God

Ever feel that your prayers are empty?
You wake up and feel spiritually empty?
You listen to teaching and it means nothing?
You read the Bible and it doesn’t speak to you?

It is an inexplicable feeling and withdrawn sense of the presence of God in your life.

St John of the Cross called it “the dark night of the soul”

Abraham felt it  (Gen 15:2)
Moses lived through it  (Deut 5:22)
Job was famous for experiencing it  (Job 30:26)
And you will experience it too.

Sometimes you just don’t have a night light that you need to find your way.

What can you do when you feel left alone in the dark?

1)     Keep going in the same direction you have been going with Him
Acknowledge that you don’t sense His presence but affirm that His Word does not change.

2)     Take time and recall all the things that God has done for you in your life 
          Remembering your past with Him will help to reveal that you have a future with Him

There IS light at the end of the tunnel.
Don’t worry over the helplessness and emptiness that you currently feel.
If you need to, get on all fours, acknowledge you are lost,
and continue to crawl to where you know you need to go.

You might run into a wall
or get hosed down with water,
but remember, the darkness is only a tunnel.
And at the end of every tunnel, there is light.

Now could somebody, just get me a towel?????

I said to the man who stood at the gate of the years,
"Give me a light that I may walk safely into the unknown." 
He said to me, "Go out into the darkness
And put your hand into the hand of God
And He shall be to you brighter than a light 
And safer than a known way."   (Author unknown)

*John O’Hara

Monday, October 5, 2015

Pastoral Prayer (October 4 World Communion Sunday) Athens First UMC



O Lord, as we prepare to break bread together, remind us that we do not receive the Sacrament alone. We are part of a long line of diverse brothers and sisters who have more in common than anything that can ever seek to divide us. We have you in common. We have the body of Christ in common.

On this World Communion Sunday, may this sacred act of receiving the Sacrament of Holy Communion be a visible expression of the unity that we have through you. Bless each church and pastor in our community so that we might shine the light of Christ throughout Athens and southeast Ohio.

May every steeple, every church sign, every church website, every church ad in the newspaper, every outreach to our community point people to your saving love in Jesus Christ. Thank you for this shared mission of all our churches.

As we reflect on what it means to be brothers and sisters in Christ, we especially think of those who are struggling with health concerns, grieving the loss of loved ones, wrestling in their faith, and facing times of transition. We share in their struggles because we are part of the same family. We are part of your family.

Thank you for the many ways that you remind us of just how expansive your church family is, like when we go on a missions trip and we are welcomed by Christians who speak a different language, like when a college student who visits our church for the first time feels so welcomed that she wants to invite her college friends to attend with her, like the homebound member who prays for her church every day even though he is unable to attend on Sunday mornings, like the pre-school parents who bring their children to our church each week because their children are loved and welcomed here.


Thank you for these many ways that we are all part of your family, O God. And now, as your children and as brothers and sisters together, we pray together saying, “Our Father…”

Sunday, October 4, 2015

Sermon (October 4) by Rev. Robert McDowell - "Brothers & Sisters"


     There’s a little phrase in our Hebrews scripture reading this morning that really got my attention. It’s found in verse 11 where we are told that Jesus isn’t ashamed to call us “brothers and sisters.”
     Brothers and sisters.
     Every time I begin at a new church, people in the congregation will tell me, “Watch what you say because everybody is related to someone around here.”
     I served a small country church early in my ministry. There were two ladies in who did everything in that church or at least it seemed like they did.  The one lady had dark hair and the other lady’s hair was completely white and they didn’t look alike at all.
     It wasn’t until my last month in that church that someone told me they were sisters! I didn’t know that! Everybody assumed I knew! I was there four years and I had no clue! Fortunately, I can’t remember ever saying anything negative about either one of them!
     When I was attending my home church in Pennsylvania, the pastor had me serve as a worship leader on Sunday mornings. On several of those Sundays, my brother would offer special music.
     When my brother was done singing, it would be my turn to read the scripture lesson. And I would always say the same lame comment that would always get a cheap laugh from the congregation.
     I just couldn’t resist.  I would say, “Thank you for your beautiful music, ‘Brother, David.’”
     But it’s true. We’re not just biological brothers. We’re also spiritual brothers like how the author of our Hebrews scripture reading means it.
     We might not call each other “brothers and sisters” like some denominations do, but that’s who we are. We are brothers and sisters in Christ.
     Just because we’re brothers and sisters in Christ, doesn’t mean that we look alike or share the same opinions. Like those two sisters, one with black hair and the other with white hair, on the outside, you might never be able to tell that we are related, but we are.
     We’re related because of our common connection with Jesus Christ. Jesus is who makes us brothers and sisters.
     And seeing ourselves as brothers and sisters doesn’t mean that it’s always easy to get along and be in fellowship. Maybe that’s why the bible uses this language of brothers and sisters as often as it does. We need to be reminded that we are part of God’s family through Jesus Christ.
     This is one of the reasons that we observe World Communion Sunday each year. It’s not only important to see each other as brothers and sisters in this place, but also with churches and other denominations throughout the world.
     Even in the United Methodist denomination, we have so much diversity. For example, both George Bush and Hillary Clinton are United Methodist. Last time I checked, they don’t see eye to eye on many issues. And yet, they are brothers and sisters in Christ and they represent the wide diversity in our denomination.
     I was at the Steelers/Ravens game this past Thursday night in Pittsburgh. Those teams don’t like each other at all. The fans can be brutal. Steelers fans might see each other as brothers and sisters in support of their team, but they certainly don’t feel very brotherly toward the Raven fans. The same is true of how Ravens fans feel about Steelers fans.
     This is what makes the church unique in a world of we’s and they’s. We might disagree with each other over what color the nursery carpet should be.
     We might have differing opinions on the meaning of scripture. Our thoughts on favorite hymns will probably be all over the board, but what keeps us together is that we always remember that we are brothers and sisters of Christ.
     This is the reason why we think twice before saying something hurtful about another person in the church. This is the reason why we are more prone to offer an encouraging word rather than a critical word to someone. It’s because we remember scriptures like this one from Hebrews that reminds us that we are brothers and sisters.
     There are also many Christian denominations that are very different from the church we attend and the United Methodist Church in general. They have different ways of worshipping. They have different methods in finding a pastor. They have different views on what a Sacrament is or isn’t.
     All of these differences, and yet on this day, this day we call, “World Communion Sunday,” we remember that in spite of all of our differences, we are brothers and sisters in Christ.
     Rachel Held Evans is a Christian blogger, author, and gifted speaker. She’s not United Methodist even though her speaking circuit includes a lot of United Methodist settings.
     Rachel’s recent book is called, Searching for Sunday, where she talks about her spiritual journey in finding a church that she can call home. Rachel is in her early 30s and because she is a young adult, her journey gives us a glimpse into how her generation views organized religion.
     In one of her chapters, she writes, “At last count, there are nearly as many denominations in Christianity as there are trees growing in a forest. Each one looks different – beautiful and broken in its own way – but we all share the same DNA.”
     “We tend to lament this seemingly endless parceling of Christianity (which, let’s face it,” she writes, “can indeed get out of hand,) but I’m not convinced the pursuit of greater unity means rejecting denominationalism altogether.”
     “A worldwide movement of more than two billion people reaching every continent and spanning thousands of cultures for over two thousand years can’t expect homogeneity. And the notion that a single tradition owns the lockbox on truth is laughable, especially when the truth we’re talking is God.”
     “We might instead think of the various Christian traditions as different facets of a diamond refracting the same light, or as workers tending to a shared garden but with unique tasks, or as a single body made of many interconnected parts.”
     “Our differences can be cause for celebration when we believe the same Spirit that sings through a pipe organ can sing through an electric guitar, a Gregorian chant, or a gospel choir – though perhaps not at the same time! – and that we each hear the Spirit best at a different pitch.”
     Rachel goes on to write, “In other words, unity does not require uniformity. Jesus said his Father’s house has many rooms.”
     “In this metaphor, I like to imagine the Presbyterians hanging out in the library, the Baptists running the kitchen, the Anglicans setting the table, the Anabaptists washing feet with the hose in the backyard, the Lutherans making liturgy for the laundry, the Methodists stoking the fire in the hearth, the Catholics keeping the family history, the Pentecostals throwing open all the windows and doors to let more people in.”
     I like what Rachel is conveying in her book. She’s saying that Christian denominations may have their unique approaches to the faith, but the main thing to remember is that even with all of our differences, we are brothers and sisters in Christ.
          In one of the churches where I served as pastor, I became friends with a non-denominational pastor.  He was the founding pastor of a new church in town and they were getting ready to celebrate their fifth birthday anniversary as a congregation.
     He invited me to preach for their special Sunday morning worship celebration that I gladly accepted.  While I was honored that he chose me, this mainline denomination pastor to speak at their special ceremony. I was also a little intimidated because I knew that our churches were very different with our worship styles.
     I don’t think that I have ever experienced a louder worship service than the one I attended that day when I spoke at his church.  I mean, it was really loud.  Drums, guitars, and lots of singing. Lots of singing.  Their worship service that day lasted two and a half hours.
     About an hour into the service, and knowing that I still had another twenty or so  minutes before I was to preach, I needed to go to the restroom. Even while I was in the restroom, the music was incredibly loud.  It’s the kind of worship that even if you’re in the restroom, you won’t miss a thing.
     So I go back into the worship auditorium…notice that I didn’t say sanctuary, and finally it’s time for me to preach.  I began by congratulating them on their five-year birthday celebration. 
     This was an incredible church because they were reaching a lot of people through their recovery ministries and helping people who were struggling with addictions.  They were doing a lot of really wonderful ministry in our community.
     And then I said, “Our two churches are very different, though.” I said that by this time I would already had lunch because our worship services are only an hour long.  And they laughed.
     And then I said, “You’re church is celebrating five years and next year, my church will be celebrating our 200th anniversary.” And the people applauded which was really nice of them.
     And then I said, “The biggest difference between our two churches is that the music here at your church is a lot louder than at my church and I mean a lot louder.” I said, “For example, before worship, you hand out ear plugs because the music is so loud.  At my church, we hand out hearing aids.”
      After the worship service, so many people came up to me to thank me for sharing with them on their special anniversary. They were so supportive and loving. I could see why they were a growing church.
     They saw themselves as a family, as brothers and sisters in Christ. I became one of their brothers that day, even though I had to get my hearing checked later that week.
     No, it wasn’t a church I would prefer to attend, but thank God they were part of our community.
     Each church and denomination offers a unique history and approach to the Christian faith. We’re not all meant to be exactly the same. Some churches are able to reach people that other churches are not as equipped to reach.
     On this World Communion Sunday, we are reminded to pray for churches all around the world who are seeking to live out their faith. We are reminded that the church is bigger than one church or one denomination. We are part of one great big world-wide communion.

     The author of Hebrews is right. We are brothers and sisters in Christ.